Visibility9 min read

Google reviews in the trades: ask, reply, report what's unfair

How to ask for Google reviews fairly after a job, reply to criticism calmly and report unfair reviews through the route Google provides for this.

A man with a grey beard and a black hooded jacket stands smiling in a workshop with large multi-pane windows and looks at a tablet in his hands.

The bathroom is finished, the customer is happy, and at the handover she says: "I'll write you a review." Then everyday life takes over and nothing happens. Two weeks later your profile shows one star and the sentence "Never again", from a name you can't find in any of your job lists. Many businesses know both situations.

This article is for trade businesses (Handwerk) and local service providers who have set up their Google Business Profile and now want a fixed way of handling reviews. How to create the link or QR code for reviews and what else matters in the profile is covered in the article Google Business Profile: 10 points you control yourself. This one is about what comes after: asking, replying and reporting what's unfair.

In short

  • Ask every customer the same way: at the same moment, with the same words, without a reward and without filtering anyone out first.
  • By email or WhatsApp only with consent: according to the German Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH), a review request by email is advertising, even inside the invoice email.
  • Reply factually: short, polite, without the customer's data. Your reply is mainly read by future customers.
  • Only report violations: Google removes reviews that break its policies. Criticism you don't like stays up.
  • If someone tries to extort you, don't pay: secure evidence and report it via Google's own form.

What Google doesn't allow, even on a small scale

The basic rules are in the article on the Business Profile: no discounts or free services for reviews, don't ask only happy customers, don't stop anyone from leaving a negative review. According to Google's policy on fake engagement, there are a few more points that easily happen in day-to-day trade work:

  • No quotas for employees. According to Google, it is prohibited to instruct staff to request a certain number of reviews or reviews with certain content. "Every fitter gets three stars this week" is not allowed.
  • No pressure on site. According to Google, customers must not be pressured while they are still on site. Holding out your phone and waiting next to them until the review is sent counts as pressure.
  • No reviews from your own circle. According to Google, content with a conflict of interest is not allowed, for example from current or former employees, from contractual partners or from family. Your sister quickly giving you five stars falls under this too.
  • No incentive to change criticism. Offering a discount if a negative review is removed or edited is also prohibited according to Google.

Bought or commissioned reviews don't just break Google's rules. According to the annex to the German Act against Unfair Competition (UWG, No. 23c), submitting or commissioning fake reviews is always unlawful towards consumers.

Asking after the job: a fixed routine

So you don't have to think about it every time, a routine that is the same for every job helps:

  1. The moment: the acceptance or handover (Abnahme), when the work is finished. Not in the middle of the job, not weeks later.
  2. Who asks: the person who finishes the job. That can be the boss or the fitter, as long as it's clear beforehand.
  3. The question: neutral, not about stars. For example: "We'd be glad if you wrote a few words on Google about how it went for you. Honestly, even if something wasn't right." Not: "If you were happy, please give us five stars." According to Google, it is prohibited to ask specifically for positive reviews.
  4. Something to take away: a small card with a QR code in the handover folder or on the paper invoice. Then the customer can write later, in peace.
  5. Ask everyone: including the customer where things didn't go smoothly. Filtering people out here is exactly what Google prohibits.

By email or WhatsApp: ask first, then send

Many would like to email the link right along with the invoice. According to the Bundesgerichtshof (judgment of 10.07.2018, VI ZR 225/17), this is not permitted without consent. The case was about a seller who asked for a review in the invoice email. The BGH classified this as advertising, even though the invoice itself was permitted. Without prior consent, it was an interference with the customer's general right of personality. According to the judgment, a business can reasonably be expected to give the customer the chance to object to further advertising already at the time of purchase.

In practice, for your business this means: when confirming the order or at the handover, ask whether you may send the review link by email or WhatsApp, and note down the answer. The judgment concerned an email. With WhatsApp or SMS, take the same care.

Note: This article gives an overview and is not legal advice. As of: November 2026.

Replying factually: templates for typical cases

To reply, open your Business Profile, choose "Read reviews" ("Rezensionen lesen") and then "Reply" ("Antworten") on the review. Google recommends replying briefly, in a friendly and helpful way, not revealing the customer's private information and not making them offers.

In the trades, "no private information" means very concretely: no street, no location of the job, no job amount, no details from the customer's home. Not even if you want to show that you know the case.

A few templates you can adapt:

  • Stars without text: "Thank you for your review. We're glad everything worked out. Best regards, [name]"
  • Praise with details: "Thanks for the kind words about the new bathroom. We'll gladly pass the praise on to the team. Best regards, [name]"
  • Justified criticism: "You're right, we were late on the second day and didn't let you know. We're sorry. We're happy to talk it through with you again, please call us on the number in our profile. [name]"
  • Criticism you see differently: "Thank you for your feedback. We see some points differently and would be glad to sort this out with you directly. Please get in touch on the number in our profile. [name]"
  • No customer found: "Unfortunately we can't find a job under your name. If you were our customer, please get in touch so we can clear this up. [name]"

A few rules that help when writing:

  • Sleep on it first if a review annoys you. Then reply.
  • No discussion in the profile. One reply, then the conversation by phone or in person.
  • Sign with your name. It feels more personal than "your team".
  • Don't put advertising in every reply. One sentence of thanks is enough.

Reporting what's unfair: the route according to Google

Reporting only makes sense if a review breaks Google's policies. Typical cases according to Google: spam, insults or vulgar language, content with a conflict of interest, for example from a competitor who wants to damage your reputation, or unusual volumes and patterns of reviews. According to its own help pages, Google does not remove a review that is unpleasant but factual.

Reporting in the Business Profile:

  1. Open your Business Profile and choose "Read reviews" ("Rezensionen lesen").
  2. Tap the report icon next to the review.
  3. Choose a reason, for example "Spam".
  4. Choose "Send report" ("Bericht senden").

Checking the status and appealing: in the review management tool linked from Google's help pages, you can see the status of your report. According to Google there are three statuses: "Decision pending" ("Entscheidung steht aus"), "Report reviewed, no policy violation" ("Meldung überprüft, kein Richtlinienverstoß") and "Escalated" ("Eskaliert"). In the second case you can appeal once, for up to ten reviews. You'll get the result by email. According to Google, the review usually takes several days.

In case of extortion: if someone threatens bad reviews and demands money or services, Google has its own reporting form. According to Google's help, you should not engage with the demand, not pay and secure evidence immediately: screenshots of the messages with date and sender, links to the reviews and the time from which the bad reviews started. Even then, removal is not guaranteed.

While the report is pending, you can still reply factually, for example with the "No customer found" template. Anyone who reads the profile later will see that you're taking care of it.

If, in your view, a review states false facts and harms you, that's a question for a lawyer. Google's reporting route only checks its policies.

Showing reviews on your own website

Many embed their Google reviews on their website or quote individual voices. According to § 5b Abs. 3 UWG, it then counts as essential information whether and how you ensure that the reviews shown come from customers who actually used your service. So write a short, honest note near the reviews about where they come from and whether you check them. Don't claim a check you don't do. How to word this for your site is best clarified with your legal adviser.

Checklist for your routine

  • A fixed moment for asking for a review, for example the handover.
  • A neutral sentence for everyone who asks, without stars and without a reward.
  • A card with a QR code in the handover folder or on the paper invoice.
  • Consent for sending the link by email or WhatsApp is asked for and noted.
  • No quotas for employees, no reviews from family or team.
  • Templates for praise, criticism and "no customer" are ready.
  • One person checks the profile once a week and replies.
  • The reporting route and the extortion form are known, screenshots are secured.
  • Reviews on the website say where they come from.

How we can help

You can't buy or control reviews, but you can make the routine around them simple. In the area of Website & visibility we set up your Google Business Profile with you, create a card with a QR code for the handover, write suitable reply templates and build the consent question into your enquiry or order form. If you want to show reviews on your website, we make sure it's clear where they come from. We support you with data protection, but we do not replace legal advice. You'll find more about typical processes on the page Trades & home services.

In the free initial consultation we look together at your profile and your routine after the job. If you can handle it well yourself, we'll tell you that too. We'll get back to you promptly, the way you prefer: by email or by phone.

#Google Rezensionen#Bewertungen#Google Unternehmensprofil#Handwerk#UWG

Sources & further reading

  1. Google Maps: Verbotene und eingeschränkt zulässige Inhalte (Gefälschte Interaktionen) support.google.com
  2. Google Unternehmensprofil-Hilfe: Tipps für mehr Rezensionen und gute Antworten support.google.com
  3. Google Unternehmensprofil-Hilfe: Unangemessene Rezensionen melden support.google.com
  4. LTO: BGH zur Bewertungsbitte in der Rechnungsmail (Urteil vom 10.07.2018, VI ZR 225/17) lto.de
  5. § 5b UWG: Wesentliche Informationen, Abs. 3 zu Verbraucherbewertungen (Gesetze im Internet) gesetze-im-internet.de